sunset over tokyo, japan

How much does El Niño affect global temperature

sunset over tokyo, japan
Sunset over Tokyo, Japan (CC0).

Every day, thousands of measurements are taken across the world by weather stations, ships, satellites, floating buoys and weather balloons. Scientists combine these different data sources together to take the Earth’s temperature and see how it is changing over time

January 20, 2017 — The graph below shows the average temperature of the Earth’s surface since 1951, as measured by the US National Aeronautic and Space Administration (NASA).

You can see from the blue line that global temperatures have risen markedly since the 1950s. But rather than a smooth climb, there are lots of ups and downs from year to year.

This week, scientists confirmed that 2016 was the warmest year in recorded history, beating the previous record set in 2015. On top of the overall upward trend, this means the world has now experienced three consecutive record-warm years for the first time since record-taking began.

The El Niño effect

Scientists know that greenhouse gases from human activity accumulate in the atmosphere, trapping heat and causing global temperatures to rise. But natural factors can nudge global temperatures up or down in any given year, too.

A natural phenomenon in the Pacific, known as El Niño, tends to boost global temperature in years when an event occurs. Its cooler counterpart, La Niña, drags temperatures down.

The red line in the graph above shows the NASA global temperature record with the effects of El Niño and La Niña removed.

Once you remove the El Niño/La Niña signal, you can see the warm peaks associated with strong El Niños in 1982/3 and 1997/8 appear less pronounced. Notably, 2016 is still the hottest year on record by quite some margin, even once you remove the effect of the strong El Niño.

Changes in solar activity and volcanic eruptions can affect global temperature, too. The yellow line in the graph above shows the same NASA global temperature record, but this time with the effects of all the major natural influences on climate – El Niño/La Niña, solar activity and volcanic eruptions – taken out.

The strong cooling effect of the Mount Pinatubo volcano eruption in 1992 is particularly visible (yellow vs red line). At the same time, however, a strong El Niño that year gave global temperature a boost, with the actual observed global temperature ending up in the middle.

Upward trend

With all the major natural influences removed, Earth’s temperature over the last few decades still shows ups and downs from year to year, albeit less pronounced ones. The fingerprint of rising greenhouse gases is, say scientists, nonetheless clear in the upward march of global surface temperature.

It’s worth noting that there are at least two other major global temperature datasets, including the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and the UK Met Office/University of East Anglia.

Both contain known data gaps in the Arctic, however. Given the Arctic is warming faster than the global average, this suggests that they are likely to be underestimating global temperatures.

Two groups of scientists have constructed a timeseries of the temperature in Earth’s troposphere, using data collected by satellites. Though both can tell us about climate change and the impact of El Niño/La Niña, the satellite and surface records measure very different quantities and aren’t directly comparable, as detailed in this Carbon Brief explainer.

carbon brief  by Roz Pidcock | Carbon Brief